If there's a "God" or "Godess" that is 'worthy' of my admiration/devotion/whatever, they'll chat with me directly.
I have done my share of "beating people on the head" with the Bible before I learned that that is as ineffective as it is unBiblical technique. So I wont try to "preach" to you, just mention how funny your statement sounds. I am sure you acknowledge that obama is the President of the United States of America, but you have only seen "proof" of it in the news, print and crazy people on street corners telling it happened. ANY who are you to think that obam should give you a personal phone call pleading you acknowledge him as President? The Bible is a book of Faith AND history and evidence, you can reject it if you want but reality is that when you die there is no coming back to change your mind. My advice is to debate now while you have the opportunity with the purpose of finding truth, NOT just to argue people out of believing.
IP: Logged
11:55 AM
82-T/A [At Work] Member
Posts: 25517 From: Florida USA Registered: Aug 2002
How refreshing it would be to have a candidate come out and say "I have no more knowledge or proof of the existence of God than any of the rest of you.. I am running for president based on what I think I can do to help the country, not on who my voters think I believe in when i kneel down to pray."
At that point, it would not matter what religion he/she is.. because they professed wanting to help our country over all else.
I would be down with that.
For the record, I have never known a presidential candidate (that won) that did so based on religion, other than Jimmy Carter. In the 70s, Jimmy Carter won as a result of his strong Christian values that he espoused. Aside from that, I don't know anyone that campaigned on it. All other presidents of modern times have essentially been Christian, but I have yet to see them base all of their legislative reasoning and decisions on that.
From my standpoint, I haven't seen a president actually push his religion... not withstanding of course any nonsense that comes from the media criticizing it.
IP: Logged
01:14 PM
2.5 Member
Posts: 43235 From: Southern MN Registered: May 2007
“The Bible records God speaking audibly to people many times (Exodus 3:14; Joshua 1:1; Judges 6:18; 1 Samuel 3:11; 2 Samuel 2:1; Job 40:1; Isaiah 7:3; Jeremiah 1:7; Acts 8:26; 9:15 – this is just a small sampling). There is no biblical reason why God could not or would not speak to a person audibly today. With the hundreds of times the Bible records God speaking, we have to remember that they occur over the course of 4,000 years of human history. God speaking audibly is the exception, not the rule. Even in the biblically recorded instances of God speaking, it is not always clear whether it was an audible voice, an inner voice, or a mental impression.
God does speak to people today. First, God speaks to us through His Word (2 Timothy 3:16-17). Isaiah 55:11 tells us, “So is my word that goes out from my mouth: it will not return to me empty, but will accomplish what I desire and achieve the purpose for which I sent it.” The Bible records God’s words, everything we need to know in order to be saved and live the Christian life. Second Peter 1:3 declares, “His divine power has given us everything we need for life and godliness through our knowledge of Him who called us by his own glory and goodness.”
Second, God speaks through impressions, events, and thoughts. God helps us to discern right from wrong through our consciences (1 Timothy 1:5; 1 Peter 3:16). God is in the process of conforming our minds to think His thoughts (Romans 12:2). God allows events to occur in our lives to direct us, change us, and help us to grow spiritually (James 1:2-5; Hebrews 12:5-11). First Peter 1:6-7 reminds us, “In this you greatly rejoice, though now for a little while you may have had to suffer grief in all kinds of trials. These have come so that your faith—of greater worth than gold, which perishes even though refined by fire—may be proved genuine and may result in praise, glory and honor when Jesus Christ is revealed.”
Finally, God may sometimes speak audibly to people. It is highly doubtful, though, that this occurs as often as some people claim it does. Again, even in the Bible, God speaking audibly is the exception, not the ordinary. If anyone claims that God has spoken to him/her, always compare what is said with what the Bible says. If God were to speak today, His words would be in full agreement with what He has said in the Bible (2 Timothy 3:16-17). God does not contradict Himself.” http://www.gotquestions.org/God-still-speak.html
-
“…We have something the Old Testament saints didn’t – the complete Scriptures, which are the inspired words of God, to read and study and meditate upon. The Apostle Paul tells us that “All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness, so that the man of God may be thoroughly equipped for every good work” (2 Timothy 3:16-17). Therefore, application of God’s written Word to our lives is just as effective and comforting to us as hearing His audible voice would be. If we have questions about a spiritual topic or decision we are facing, we can go to the Bible, confident that the words there are just as authoritative and good as God’s own voice. He has promised not to lead us contrary to the teachings and promises in the Bible (Titus 1:2).
Another important thing to remember is that only a believer – a person saved by His grace through faith in the Lord Jesus – can recognize God’s voice. Jesus said, “My sheep listen to my voice; I know them, and they follow me” (John 10:27). This implies that Jesus’ own flock will recognize His voice because they know Him, having learned about Him from the Scriptures. Reading the Bible creates an “imprint” of His voice in their minds, and when He speaks to their hearts, it is obvious to them that He is the one speaking.
The more time believers spend in the Word, listening to God, and speaking in return to Him in prayer, the easier it will be to recognize His voice and His leading in our lives. We should know Him so well, because we know His voice through the Scriptures, that it will be obvious to us when He prompts or leads our conscience by the Holy Spirit, or if He speaks in an audible way. It is important to remember that the lack of an audible voice from God in the life of a believer is not in any way a sign that God does not love that believer, or that He is displeased with him. We should seek to know the Lord through the Word, not through extra-biblical revelation, because as Peter tells us, even though he and the other apostles saw Jesus in His glory and heard the voice of God coming down from Heaven, we now have “a more sure word of prophecy” (2 Peter 1:18-19).” http://www.compellingtruth.org/voice-of-God.html
The Bible is a book of Faith AND history and evidence,
Sorry, but i just don't see it as a book of history or evidence. The faith part is right, as thats all the book has going for it.. The STORIES which is all they are, where written after Jesus died, long after.. No actual witnesses wrote that book, nobody from Jesus lifetime, wrote that book.. No real historical facts either, other than places mentioned, some that may have not even been real.. Of course then the book was changed, parts omitted that the church thought went against their vision of Jesus as divine, so those parts where just left out.. Then men of power changed the book many times over the centuries to fit their own purpose and wants.
I don't see how anyone could see any of that "historical evidence" as proof of God.. When in reality its just a book written by men, too control other men..
Good stories too instill fear in little kids though... Get them on the wagon early
IP: Logged
06:09 PM
bonzo Member
Posts: 1350 From: Jacksonville, FL, USA Registered: Jul 2003
Wow. This one is turning ugly. Go at it people. I will sit back and read.
What was the title of this one?
I dont see it turning "ugly", I have seen MUCH worse. The title is asking if you would vote for a muslum as President, AND BTW muslums "say" they believe in the Old Testament, so this discussion over the Bible is related. Thou not specifically about mulums as it probably should be.
IP: Logged
11:10 PM
Rickady88GT Member
Posts: 10655 From: Central CA Registered: Dec 2002
Sorry, but i just don't see it as a book of history or evidence. The faith part is right, as thats all the book has going for it.. The STORIES which is all they are, where written after Jesus died, long after.. No actual witnesses wrote that book, nobody from Jesus lifetime, wrote that book.. No real historical facts either, other than places mentioned, some that may have not even been real.. Of course then the book was changed, parts omitted that the church thought went against their vision of Jesus as divine, so those parts where just left out.. Then men of power changed the book many times over the centuries to fit their own purpose and wants.
I don't see how anyone could see any of that "historical evidence" as proof of God.. When in reality its just a book written by men, too control other men..
Good stories too instill fear in little kids though... Get them on the wagon early
I dont mind talking about religion, I dont mind answering (when I can) questions that are sincere, BUT I have to ask "Why do you feel the need to express your doubt in God so often were you obviously dont even care about the topic of the thread you post in?"
IP: Logged
11:15 PM
Patrick Member
Posts: 39042 From: Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada Registered: Apr 99
I dont mind talking about religion, I dont mind answering (when I can) questions that are sincere, BUT I have to ask "Why do you feel the need to express your doubt in God so often were you obviously dont even care about the topic of the thread you post in?"
You know that I respect you.
With that said, why do so many feel the need to express their beliefs about religion. Why can I not sit at home, and read Pennocks without some religious person(s) knocking at my door? I have never had a non believer like myself knock at my door. Although they would be treated the same way. "No thank you, but good luck, and enjoy your day."
IP: Logged
11:46 PM
Dec 28th, 2012
Rickady88GT Member
Posts: 10655 From: Central CA Registered: Dec 2002
That's just it though... a "god" wouldn't even have to spend a nickel to make a phone call.
A "god" would have the power (I suspect) to make himself/herself/itself heard to a single individual or to a billion people... no hardware required.
What could be simpler?
It would make instant "believers" out of all of us.
Yet, he/she/it only seems to converse with televangelists.
Just doesn't seem legit.
Mark me down as sceptical.
I dont blame you at all for your scepticism, given the reasons you listed. First: and foremost God said this Earth is the fingerprint of his existence. God made the Earth and everything else around it, even IF you believe in the "big bang" that "ball of mass" had to come from God. Second: who are you or I to tell God how he should conduct business? He simply chose to let himself be known to those that want to know him. Those that dont care will stay busy doing other things. God chose NOT to control us, but gave us free will. God will NOT beat us on the head like we do each other to "teach one another", God chose to give us what we need to know, and let us decide to follow or not (on our own). The Bible teaches that those who believe without seeing are more blessed than those that have seen then believed. Third: ALL people have fallen short of the glory of God. DO NOT EVERY put your faith in mankind to tell "everything" about God. You will have to actually ask God your self sincerely and humbly to reveal himself to you. Fourth: The Bible WAS NOT authored by men. God told them what to write.
IP: Logged
12:08 AM
Rickady88GT Member
Posts: 10655 From: Central CA Registered: Dec 2002
With that said, why do so many feel the need to express their beliefs about religion. Why can I not sit at home, and read Pennocks without some religious person(s) knocking at my door? I have never had a non believer like myself knock at my door. Although they would be treated the same way. "No thank you, but good luck, and enjoy your day."
The respect is mutual, in fact there are MANY people on PFF that I respect even when we have STRONG disagreements. The only thing I can say about your question is that you should ask them. I dont want to put words in their mouths. I can guess at why they may be doing it? That guess is two fold: 1) they are "working" to earn some type of spiritual points from God: 2) They actually feel that they have the truth and feel a concern for those that dont know the truth, so they want to help spread the truth (as they see it).
So just to put things in perspective, I may have maybe two visits a year from people that knock on my door, but here on PFF I have to skip over twice that many posts from people that express disbelief in threads each week. So I would think that we are more likely to be bombarded with comments against God than people knocking at the door with kindness asking to give a sales pitch for their religion? Yes I know people on PFF do boldly express faith in God in threads as well, it goes both ways.
[This message has been edited by Rickady88GT (edited 12-28-2012).]
IP: Logged
12:23 AM
Patrick Member
Posts: 39042 From: Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada Registered: Apr 99
I do see faith as having advantages. Most that believe are better off for it. If that is what one needs to be a kinder person, then so be it. It is not for me to decide. One of my tattoos says RESPECT. It is meant as a reminder to myself that our time here is finite. Respect everyone and everything. Always extend that. It comes back either way that you give it.
I used to slam the door on religious solicitors. I do not do that anymore. Why create pain? It will come back to haunt me one way or the other.
IP: Logged
01:29 AM
2.5 Member
Posts: 43235 From: Southern MN Registered: May 2007
I see questions and observations posted, frustrations, statements that appear as questions which bring to mind answers, etc. I post answers I have. Answers I believe. I suppose that is all we can do. If it helps it helps, if it doesnt, it doesn't. Most all my posts concerning faith are only in response to questions or statements left seemingly open. I have bypassed many threads though I did want to post. If its too much trouble to read or not read my responses no one has mentioned it to me.
IP: Logged
09:07 AM
2.5 Member
Posts: 43235 From: Southern MN Registered: May 2007
..where written after Jesus died, long after.. No actual witnesses wrote that book, nobody from Jesus lifetime, wrote that book..
Old Testament books in their inspired order * (Years are B.C.)
Genesis 1445 - 1405 Nahum 711 Exodus 1445 - 1405 Habakkuk 626 Leviticus 1445 - 1405 Zephaniah 626 Numbers 1445 - 1405 Haggai 520 Deuteronomy 1445 - 1405 Zechariah 520 to 518 Joshua 1067 - 1050 Malachi c. 400 Judges 1067 - 1050 Psalms 1010 - 585 1Samuel 757 to 696 Proverbs 970 to 686 2Samuel 757 to 696 Job 1660s 1Kings 757 to 696 Song of Solomon 970 to 930 2Kings 809 to 757 Ruth 1060s Isaiah 757 to 696 Lamentations 608 to 586 Jeremiah 626 to 585 Ecclesiastes 970 to 930 Ezekiel 597 to 570 Esther 585 to 572 Hosea 796 to 719 Daniel 605 to 530 Joel 595 to 585 Ezra 586 to 513 Amos 796 Nehemiah 565 to 513 Obadiah 590 1Chronicles 586 to 513 Jonah 798 2Chronicles 586 to 513 Micah 740 to 711
New Testament books in their inspired order * (Years are A.D.)
Matthew 35 1Corinthians 56 Mark 42 2Corinthians 57 Luke 59 Galatians 53 John 42 and 95 Ephesians 61 to 63 Acts 1-12 59 Philippians 61 to 63 Acts 13-15 44 to 46 Colossians 61 to 63 Acts 16-18 50 to 52 1Thessalonians 50 Acts 18-21 58 2Thessalonians 51 Acts 21-28 61 to 63 Hebrews 61 to 63 James 40 to 41 1Timothy 63 1Peter 64 to 65 2Timothy 67 2Peter 65 to 66 Titus 63 1, 2 and 3John 63 to 64 Philemon 61 to 63 Jude 66 to 67 Revelation 95 Romans 57
Notes John began the main part of his gospel in 42 A.D. but did not complete it until he was on the island of Patmos in 95 A.D.
Luke wrote Acts 1 to 13 when apostle Paul was in a Roman Caesarea prison from 58 to 60 A.D. He also wrote Acts 13-28 as he traveled with the Apostle Paul during his missionary journeys. Paul's first journey ran from 44 to 46, the second from 49 to 52, the third from 53 to 58, the fourth from 60 to 63 and the final one from 63 to 67 A.D. Paul writes five books while held as a prisoner in Rome awaiting his trial before Caesar (61 to 63)! He is released from prison in 63 A.D., conducts his fifth journey, and is back in one of Rome's prisons in 67 A.D. He writes his last epistle, a final letter to his fellow evangelist and most trusted friend Timothy, while under guard for one last time. Paul dies in the middle of 68 A.D., just weeks before Emperor Nero kills himself. http://www.biblestudy.org/m...ks-of-the-bible.html
- Also consider how long it takes to hand write pages with a quill, and how rare this was.
"If you look into works produced in antiquity, about alexander the great and so forth (written almost 500 years after his reign which are considered historic fact), you find out that the books about jesus were reletively written extremely soon after the fact. remember that 60AD society was oral, paper was not produced in great quantity, orating the story would have been much more sensible rather than writing it on paper."
"I think it is because the apostles were too busy trying to spread the word and running away from people that were trying to kill them. Also, back in those days it was real expensive to have a manuscript printed (not printed like today, it would have been written by hand). It would have had to be printed on animal hyde or something like that. You had to have alot of money, so I think when they started to get things like this, they were able to have these books made."
-
"Usually letters were written on parchment, which was worked leather, or on papyrus. Papyrus was a composition of thin, crossed strips of an Egyptian river reed. It varied in thickness and smoothness, and was formed into sheets measuring about 10 or 12 inches wide. Neither parchment nor papyrus offered the smooth writing surface we expect in paper today.
A pen was made from a split reed or a goose quill. The sticky ink was a mixture of carbon and glue or gum. With rough quality papyrus writing was very difficult and the scribe struggled intently to form each letter.
...Because writing was a tedious task, only two or three hours in a working day could be devoted to a letter. It is estimated that the Letter to the Romans must have occupied Paul and his secretary at least 32 days at three hours a day, or a maximum of 49 days at two hours a day." https://melkite.org/faith/faith-worship/st-paul
[This message has been edited by 2.5 (edited 12-28-2012).]
I dont mind talking about religion, I dont mind answering (when I can) questions that are sincere, BUT I have to ask "Why do you feel the need to express your doubt in God so often were you obviously dont even care about the topic of the thread you post in?"
Probably for the same reasons you feel the need to show your belief in god.. Just like you, im just expressing my own beliefs and views.. My beliefs may clash with yours.. So your saying i should stay quiet because you don't like or agree with what i believe? Not very Christian of you now is it..
quote
Originally posted by Patrick:
How convenient! Convince the masses that they will be "more blessed" if they can be won over with less effort.
Sorry, but even though I'm a long way from Missouri, it's still necessary to "show me".
[EDIT] Rick, I just wanted to add that although I don't believe a word that you said, I still appreciate your thoughtful response.
Well as we all know, fear is the best motivator, and easiest way to control the masses.
[This message has been edited by Jonesy (edited 12-28-2012).]
IP: Logged
11:06 AM
2.5 Member
Posts: 43235 From: Southern MN Registered: May 2007
Probably for the same reasons you feel the need to show your belief in god.. Just like you, im just expressing my own beliefs and views.. My beliefs may clash with yours.. So your saying i should stay quiet because you don't like or agree with what i believe? Not very Christian of you now is it..
I havent noticed you express a belief, or explain one. Only try and contradict or distract from someone elses.
I havent noticed you express a belief, or explain one. Only try and contradict or distract from someone elses.
I figured my arguments against religion would have given you an idea on where i stand on that issue. But i have explained quite a few times in the past my beliefs in how things came too be, as i follow science, if you didn't know that, i guess you wernt paying attention to my posts in other topics over the years.. Interesting how you pay attention now, when im giving my opinons that you don't like about your religion.. (assuming your religious)...
But if you want to say my using facts and truths instead of "faith" is a "contradiction" i can't help you there, you faith based guys will have to figure that out on your own, which would be hard since facts and truths tend to clash with your little black book of stories..
[This message has been edited by Jonesy (edited 12-28-2012).]
IP: Logged
01:04 PM
2.5 Member
Posts: 43235 From: Southern MN Registered: May 2007
I figured my arguments against religion would have given you an idea on where i stand on that issue. But i have explained quite a few times in the past my beliefs in how things came too be, as i follow science, if you didn't know that, i guess you wernt paying attention to my posts in other topics over the years.. Interesting how you pay attention now, when im giving my opinons that you don't like about your religion.. (assuming your "insert prefered religion here")...
But if you want to say my using facts and truths instead of "faith" is a "contradiction" i can't help you there.
For example. Do you believe in a soul? You mention facts and truths, but did not comment on my post about when the bible was written.
IP: Logged
01:15 PM
Tony Kania Member
Posts: 20794 From: The Inland Northwest Registered: Dec 2008
I do. But I believe that a soul is energy. We are able to give or recieve energy. While I believe that we all have a soul, the basic element that makes it such, is electrons and nuetrons. I do not think that there is one area of the body dedicated to the soul. In my way of thought, it is a conglamorant of each and every cell in our bodies working together.
My beliefs on the writings of the Bible are just that. Mine. I believe that I have never met a person that has not lied at least once.
IP: Logged
01:35 PM
Lilchief Member
Posts: 1759 From: Vevay,Indiana Registered: Feb 2004
I dont mind talking about religion, I dont mind answering (when I can) questions that are sincere, BUT I have to ask "Why do you feel the need to express your doubt in God so often were you obviously dont even care about the topic of the thread you post in?"
quote
Originally posted by Jonesy:
Probably for the same reasons you feel the need to show your belief in god.. Just like you, im just expressing my own beliefs and views.. My beliefs may clash with yours.. So your saying i should stay quiet because you don't like or agree with what i believe? Not very Christian of you now is it..
I believe like you do that we should ALL be able to express our views and opinions and beliefs. I did not in any way ask or tell or imply that you should "stay quiet". If anything at all I asked you to explain more? It does not bother me that we have disagreements, not sure how you thought that? But IF in some way I led you to think so, I apologize. I am not out to get you so you can put the shield down. Or if you want, we will just drop it? It's your call, I am available if you ever want to ask me any questions.