Oil pan gasket has developed a leak

Looks like FUN to replace, too!
Question is, to gasket, or not to gasket? Looking at the (apparently two) gaskets available, they come in four pieces: rubber ends, and cork sides.

The cork valve cover gaskets are crap, so I'm not crazy about using some on the pan, which is significantly more difficult to replace. What should I do? Use all silicone (Permatex Right Stuff), use silicone in place of the cork and use the rubber with silicone on them, silicone on both faces of all four gaskets with extra in the corners where the seams are?