Did you wire it as such (viewed from the front side)?

Try scanning it as different year 91-93. Have you changed the chip in it? How did you wire it up (DeVille, SeVille, Fleetwood, etc)?
I know some people have had some problems with scanning thier 4.9 - but non eof them had actually gotten back saying if they figured the problem out or not. Could be that the scan tool is not compatiable with the 4.9 (it must be OBD1 compatiable - basically if it comes with the correct cable to fit the plug, then it is fine)?
Also in the Caddy diagrams, there is a jumper between 2 of the pins on the ALDL plug - it could be that this scanner is looking at the jumpered pin vs the 1 in the diagram I posted (I do know that diagram I posted works fine on a couple different scanners, but can not comment on them all).

Hope that helps and please keep us posted on what you find.