My steel stick shift adapter plates used to weigh 18.5 lbs. the Alum ones I use now are 6.5 lbs. The alum. is quite expensive to save only 12 pounds but Alum. is what everybody wanted.
The Adapter plate you refer to are Zumwalt copies.
As far as Alum vs Steel, there is no real side load or pulling load on an adapter plate. So provided proper design, I don't think there is any difference between the 2 materials other than weight.
Archie
BTW, my stick adapter plate is $395 and the F/W is $250 so you can have the good stuff for about the same price as the copies. 
A
------------------
[This message has been edited by Archie (edited 04-26-2002).]