737 crash in China (Page 4/8)
maryjane MAR 24, 12:34 AM

quote
Originally posted by 82-T/A [At Work]:
I guess that's really what I was asking.

I was on a KLM 747 Series 100 back in the early to mid 1980s on a flight from Cairo to Skipol (Netherlands). The plane just "fell" ... for lack of a better explanation. We hadn't experienced any turbulence before then... but the plane was in a freefall for what felt like at least half a minute, if not more. Maybe it was less than that, but it felt like forever. Anyone who wasn't buckled in, flew up into the air. Many of the oxygen masks (sporadically, not all of them) dropped... maybe 1/8th or less of them on the plane from what I could see. When the plane finally "came to," everyone who was now in the air or plastered on the ceiling of the plane fell back down in a large crash, along with a couple of the luggage compartments. There was a lot of screaming, and a lot of crying.

I was buckled in, as was my dad's secretary who was flying with me (sigh... I know). I don't remember being "scared" so to speak, but I was shocked. I know how much it sucked, and I hate to think that the people in that plane experienced that for a prolonged amount of time. Almost like drowning... long and drawn out.



Perhaps Blackrams has had it happen too, as I have in a helicopter. Cruising along in clear calm air at about 1500' and suddenly the aircraft just 'drops' straight vertically (not nose down) about 10-15 ft then continues on as normal. The 1st time it happened while I was on board the most experienced pilot in the CH53 program was at the controls abput 1/2way between Danang and Chulai. "There's that old transient T(?) problem" the pilot remarked.
Here's the same pilot a few years earlier
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VC2E8RJE3Jo

(The T problem he remarked on is in referenceto some adjustment on a sensor with the nomenclature of 'T' and a number which I have forgotten. (T-6 maybe) Located on a panel between left gunner window and bulkhead betwwen cargi bay and flight deck and was one of several little screws you adjusted for different 'stuff'.)
blackrams MAR 24, 04:45 AM

quote
Originally posted by maryjane:


Perhaps Blackrams has had it happen too, as I have in a helicopter. Cruising along in clear calm air at about 1500' and suddenly the aircraft just 'drops' straight vertically (not nose down) about 10-15 ft then continues on as normal. The 1st time it happened while I was on board the most experienced pilot in the CH53 program was at the controls abput 1/2way between Danang and Chulai. "There's that old transient T(?) problem" the pilot remarked.
Here's the same pilot a few years earlier
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VC2E8RJE3Jo

(The T problem he remarked on is in referenceto some adjustment on a sensor with the nomenclature of 'T' and a number which I have forgotten. (T-6 maybe) Located on a panel between left gunner window and bulkhead betwwen cargi bay and flight deck and was one of several little screws you adjusted for different 'stuff'.)



Love the video Don. Reminds me of some of the things I tried at one point or another in my time as a mission pilot. As a Test Pilot, it was all business and not nearly as much fun although, I've had a few experiences that could have ended differently had I not practiced auto rotation often and developed a pretty good technique for putting the aircraft back on the ground without the assistance of a power plant. Over my entire test flying career, eight engine failures give one a reason to get and stay good at auto rotations. Rule of thumb, always take the crew chief who worked on the aircraft with you on the test flight (he/she may not have your best interests at heart) and always keep the flight over a clear landing site with a good place to set her down.

I have experienced that drop in altitude while flying a UH-1 while flying IFR a few times, it always gets your attention. As to the specific cause, I always attributed it to micro bursts of downward flowing channels of air. The kind you can't see. The absolute worst situation that got my attention the most was while flying to a destination that required us to fly through an occluded front with several concentrated thunder storms. ATC was giving us guidance and directed us between some major atmospheric down pours through what he described as one or the lesser disturbances/cells. While attempting to maintain the desired and assigned altitude, we entered the cell, initially we began to climb at a rate of about 3000 feet per minute so I obviously lowered the collective to maintain altitude. When we hit the center of the cell, we dropped like a rock and the Vertical Indicator actually maxed out. Scared the crap out of me. Reminded me of my skydiving days in freefall.
Not sure what altitude we ended up at but we maintained a 90 +/- knot forward airspeed the entire time while heading what felt like straight to our demise. Thankfully eventually came out the other side of that downward column of air and back into the clean air upward moving outside and ended up at the previous assigned altitude. Scared the hell out of me and the folks in the back. I apologized but, from the looks of the rear, my apology went un-noticed, they were still throwing up their dinner. The whole event may have lasted 30 to 40 seconds but, seemed like a life time.

Have experienced similar but much shorter or faster/quicker drops like that on commercial airliners since but, nothing like that.
Edited: At this point with what is apparently known, I don't believe this was in anyway related to weather.

Rams

[This message has been edited by blackrams (edited 03-24-2022).]

82-T/A [At Work] MAR 24, 07:12 AM

quote
Originally posted by maryjane:


Perhaps Blackrams has had it happen too, as I have in a helicopter. Cruising along in clear calm air at about 1500' and suddenly the aircraft just 'drops' straight vertically (not nose down) about 10-15 ft then continues on as normal. The 1st time it happened while I was on board the most experienced pilot in the CH53 program was at the controls abput 1/2way between Danang and Chulai. "There's that old transient T(?) problem" the pilot remarked.
Here's the same pilot a few years earlier
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VC2E8RJE3Jo

(The T problem he remarked on is in referenceto some adjustment on a sensor with the nomenclature of 'T' and a number which I have forgotten. (T-6 maybe) Located on a panel between left gunner window and bulkhead betwwen cargi bay and flight deck and was one of several little screws you adjusted for different 'stuff'.)




That video is pretty awesome, seeing that helicopter do rotations in the air (or whatever the technical term is). Hahaha... that's pretty crazy.

For me, something happened to the plane, and they had to make an emergency landing in East Germany. I've told the story on here before, so I won't bore everyone. But it was definitely more than just turbulence... it was a free-fall.

Anyway, I just hope that whatever happened, it was quick, and those people didn't suffer for as long as it took for the plane to fall from the sky and finally impact.
maryjane MAR 24, 11:23 AM

quote
Originally posted by 82-T/A [At Work]:
That video is pretty awesome, seeing that helicopter do rotations in the air (or whatever the technical term is). Hahaha... that's pretty crazy.

.



That wasn't the first Sikorsky to do loops and rolls, but what is interesting is the difference between the 1968 CH53 test and the first one in 1949, specifically where the 2 test flights took place. Both took place near the Sikorsky plant in Ct, with the ch53 test out over the water starting at a relatively high altitude but in 1949, Sikorsky S-52 test pilot Tommy Thompson just let it all hang out right over the Sikorsky plant itself in the first documented and intentional helicopter loops and rolls and very close to the ground. He died of natural causes at age 82 in 2003 but not before giving up flyin helicopters for 29 years..


quote
His career came to an abrupt halt on a spring day in 1950, when he took an admiral aloft at the Navy's Lakehurst, New Jersey, base. Suddenly, a shaft snapped, and the tail rotor came apart.

Thompson skillfully kept the craft from spinning around, the usual result of such an accident. The helicopter landed hard, crushed the landing gear and tilted, while the spinning overhead rotor chewed up the ground and disintegrated. Tommy crawled out with nothing worse than a cut cheek. The admiral was shaken, but game: "All in a day's work, eh, boy?" Thompson however had walked away from more than 20 forced landings and now his fifth helicopter crash. Figuring he had stretched the law of averages too far, he replied, "Maybe for you, sir, but not for me". That night, when he got home he talked to his wife and refrained from flying again in a helicopter until 1979.


After his flying career came to a halt, he moved back to Hobart, Indiana, and began working with his father, delivering fuel oil for the Standard Oil Company. In 1979, Thompson visited the Tucson Convention Center where a large helicopter convention was taking place. He immediately was recognized for his feats during the convention and given the opportunity to pilot one of Sikorsky's S-58s.



[This message has been edited by maryjane (edited 03-24-2022).]

82-T/A [At Work] MAR 24, 12:33 PM

quote
Originally posted by maryjane:







Oh hell no... that's totally insane, I want nothing to do with that! Hahah... that guy is so close to the ground on the return... damn.
williegoat MAR 24, 02:15 PM
I'm curious. Does the pilot change the collective pitch throughout the maneuver? Is there such a thing as negative collective?
2.5 MAR 24, 05:12 PM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0dhC1s2MFBg

[This message has been edited by 2.5 (edited 03-24-2022).]

IMSA GT MAR 24, 06:00 PM

quote
Originally posted by williegoat:

I'm curious. Does the pilot change the collective pitch throughout the maneuver? Is there such a thing as negative collective?



I'm guessing that once he is facing skyward and gets slightly negative to start the roll, he changes collective to zero pitch and allows the front of the helicopter to simply be "top heavy" and fall backwards which makes the loop. Then once facing the ground he adds collective and pulls out of the dive. Just a guess though
blackrams MAR 24, 06:50 PM

quote
Originally posted by williegoat:

I'm curious. Does the pilot change the collective pitch throughout the maneuver? Is there such a thing as negative collective?


On that S 52. I have no idea, that was before my time. I suspect it was similar to what I flew but can't say with any real authority.

But, the birds I flew had a negative pitch (so to speak) on the outboard ends of the rotor blades. That pitch is what allows the helicopter to maintain rotor speed during auto rotation.
So no, the collective didn't have a negative pitch capability in the aircraft I flew.

Once showboating I.................. No, never mind, that one still scares me to this day.

Rams

[This message has been edited by blackrams (edited 03-24-2022).]

blackrams MAR 24, 06:59 PM

quote
Originally posted by 82-T/A [At Work]:

That video is pretty awesome, seeing that helicopter do rotations in the air (or whatever the technical term is). Hahaha... that's pretty crazy.




A Loop and a Roll.

And yes, one has to be a little bit nuts to do those things although some of today's aircraft can easily accomplish both. About 20 years ago (maybe longer, can't remember), the Army finally figured out it needed to teach aerial combat to helicopter pilots. Think Top Gun type school but for helicopters. I sent a few Warrant Officers to the school but, never got the opportunity myself. Any chance I may have had evaporated when I went to Test Pilot School.

Rams