Izusu 5 speed or M19 4 speed on a 3.4 DOHC (Page 1/1)
jessesmith121 DEC 19, 05:26 PM
Thoughts?

1st through 4th looks super similar but you have the added gear for economy with the 5 speed.

------------------
86 Fiero SE 5 Speed - Junkyard
84 Fiero SE 4 Speed- Sold
86 Fiero SE 6cyl 4 speed M19 - Sold
86 Fiero SE 6cyl 4 speed (25,000 miles) - Sold
87 Fiero SE 4cyl 5 Speed - Sold
86 Fiero GT 4 Speed- Sold
88 Formula 5 Speed T-top - Sold
87 Fiero SE 6cyl $ speed swapped - Sold
88 Fiero Formula 5-Speed - Sold
86 Fiero GT 4-speed - Sold
87 Fiero GT 5-Speed - Sold
Countless parts cars

fierofool DEC 19, 06:26 PM
I just became aware of an Isuzu that popped behind a 2.8 stroked to 3.1. The 4-speed is the strongest of the two. Both may be weak behind the 3.4 DOHC compared to a Getrag.
Gall757 DEC 19, 06:36 PM
The M19 is the smooth case, so it is not a good choice for a stronger engine. What you really should have is the M17 if you are not on the freeway every day.
pmbrunelle DEC 19, 06:41 PM
If you want M19 gearing, stuff it in an M17 case.

If you use the M19 as-is, then you have a transmission rated for 4-cylinder torque, just like the Isuzu, but without the 5th cog.

[This message has been edited by pmbrunelle (edited 12-19-2019).]

ltlfrari DEC 20, 08:29 AM
Had a suzy 5 speed behind my DOHC.
1st to 2nd gear jump was very wide but othe than that it was great, loped along around 2300 rpm at 65 in 5th but would still pull away if I put my foot down without having to drop a gear.
Stood up to the engine fine but I didn't go dropping the clutch either although I did enjoy some 'spirited' driving.

------------------
Anything I might say is probably worth what you paid for it, so treat it accordingly!

Dave

www.ltlfrari.com

olejoedad DEC 20, 09:13 AM
The 85-86 four speed is stronger than the Getrag.....
pmbrunelle DEC 20, 07:29 PM

quote
Originally posted by olejoedad:

The 85-86 four speed is stronger than the Getrag.....



How do you figure the Muncie is stronger than the Getrag?

I thought that they were in the same category... both being bolted to the same Fiero V6.
olejoedad DEC 20, 08:02 PM
The Getrag will push the time intermediate shaft thru the case and into the bellhousing under continued abuse.

[This message has been edited by olejoedad (edited 12-20-2019).]