I have an M8 bolt with a large captive flat washer for my alternator adjustment.
It's the style that's commonly used on the Fiero body.

The bolt is threaded into the alternator housing, so there's no nut. If your alternator housing's thread is stripped, it can be repaired with a Heli-Coil (as I did to mine).

I don't know what Fieros had stock, but this setup worked for me. I didn't have issues with the alternator losing its adjustment.
If you're looking for the Concours-restoration answer, I'm not the guy for that.
My Fiero has the SI alternator; yours will look a bit different having the CS alternator.
I agree with Ogre, I wouldn't want to use anything with star points; that would chew up the aluminium. I have the large captive flat washer expressly for the reason of avoiding damage to the aluminium bracket.