I have an '86 SE down in Corpus Christi that I am thinking about selling. I wanted to get an idea of what would be a decent price range to look at if I sold it in TX. I could ship it back to MI, but I figure someone in TX may want a good Fiero.
It was a Michigan car, undercoated when new, and only driven a few winters. No rust issues, clean car. Power windows V6 4 speed Less than 70K New tires 2 years ago GT rims CS alternator upgrade Black, some panels have been painted (replaced hood because of bad SMC on the OEM and repainted spoiler and front bumper since it was cheap enough), but I am guessing the car will need paint in the future, but it isn't bad as I think it is just starting to fade the clear in a few spots.... very little though. I will have to get photos. Interior good, minor warping I think around the surround and glove box. headlight motors work. Seats are good, no wear. Sunroof headliner will need to be replaced. Exhaust manifolds were removed and studs were used to reinstall. A/C needs a recharge, but it does work when charged (still R12) Subwoofer Struts installed in rear 2 years ago.
Man, prices are up and down on Fiero's here. I have a GT that was in close to the same shape and got it $1800. I would say find a price that makes you happy and stick to it. The right person will pay what it worth.