So, according to CBS and ABC, OBL has been in Pakistan for at least 8 months, living on a compound, in what is being described as a mansion, in a city of 90,000, not far from the capital of Pakistan, and not one single moderate or other Pakistani ever knew it?
Yeah--right. As I said long ago, LOTS of people in that region helped him move about--or knew he did, and never opened their little pie holes.
May he burn in hell and all those who knew he was there.
IP: Logged
01:15 AM
Scottzilla79 Member
Posts: 2573 From: Chicago, IL Registered: Oct 2009
Is anyone else bothered by the celebrating in the streets? Dure it is mostly stupid college kids but it just unseemly. I'm glad he's dead but I wouldn't go screaming in front of the white house or in times square.
IP: Logged
01:18 AM
WhiteDevil88 Member
Posts: 8518 From: Coastal California Registered: Mar 2007
Is anyone else bothered by the celebrating in the streets? Dure it is mostly stupid college kids but it just unseemly. I'm glad he's dead but I wouldn't go screaming in front of the white house or in times square.
Nope. I think it deserves at least as much celebration as a basketball team winning a title.
IP: Logged
01:21 AM
Blacktree Member
Posts: 20770 From: Central Florida Registered: Dec 2001
Originally posted by theBDub: Obama didn't take credit. He addressed that it was America's win. This was an awesome point. Hopefully the troops will see the light at the end of the tunnel now and have the drive to pull out with the win in short time.
quote
Originally posted by pontiackid86: I noticed that to. [sic] (kinds looked like he was pulled out of bed to give the address) but as i said. many think hes a selfish president but that statement said its an American win not a presidential win.
Huh? As soon as "I" took office, "I" ordered Leon Panetta to make this a priority. (Not even, "I reaffirmed the priority set by my predecessor.")(NOPE! "I" gave this order !!!) "I" was briefed (eight months ago). "I" ordered further investigations. "I" ordered action.
He could not even say, to those who lost loved ones in the 9/11 attacks, that "your country" would not rest, it had to be "We" (a most royal (I.e.. sovereign) "We," at that.)
quote
Originally posted by TiredGXP: Geez, can't some of you leave your political bickering aside even for this news?
I would if everyone else would. But some would "reinterpret" Obama's speech already (see above), as though 20-20 hindsight were the political necessity of the day.
For me, I find sadness in the fact that anyone would take joy in another's death. I don't care if you regard bin Laden as human, or animal. It was a life. What was done, needed to be done. Had to be done.
The fact of its doing, however necessary, is not a cause for celebration. Chants of "USA, USA" as shown outside the gates of the White House tonight, (however "big" that may make one feel) strike me as obscene. Just as did the scenes of those others dancing in the streets on 9/11/2001.
I don't have any easy answers. Would that I did. I do know that pounding our chests and going "Ungh, Ungh, Ungh" (or USA!, USA!, USA!) won't really solve any problems.
Please don't reduce yourselves to finding joy in the killing of another being. He deliberately killed others. Wantonly. He has paid the price for doing so. What had to be done, was done. None of us are any larger, or any more important, because of this.
There are more important problems in the world.
IP: Logged
01:27 AM
BMTFIERO Member
Posts: 1187 From: Beaumont, TX Registered: Dec 2007
Originally posted by Shyster: I don't have any easy answers. Would that I did. I do know that pounding our chests and going "Ungh, Ungh, Ungh" (or USA!, USA!, USA!) won't really solve any problems.
I get where you're coming from, but I would counter with the fact that it at least raises spirits. Let a country that has been riddled with economic problems and a general depressing mood celebrate and be merry, no matter the occasion.
For some people, it just floats their boat to be extra patriotic, and I would never discourage them.
"Huh? As soon as "I" took office, "I" ordered Leon Panetta to make this a priority. (Not even, "I reaffirmed the priority set by my predecessor.")(NOPE! "I" gave this order !!!) "I" was briefed (eight months ago). "I" ordered further investigations. "I" ordered action."
Sorry, Shyster, It was not a reinforced priority. Bush stated clearly that he was not that important, more than once. Obama made it a priority again. He did give the order, unless there is a CIC we aren't aware of. "I ordered action" is exactly what happened.
I get where you're coming from, but I would counter with the fact that it at least raises spirits. Let a country that has been riddled with economic problems and a general depressing mood celebrate and be merry, no matter the occasion.
For some people, it just floats their boat to be extra patriotic, and I would never discourage them.
good post.. I agree.. I am not into seeing someone die. I am not the kind of person who would wish bad things even on bad people...but everyone in this country should at least be relieved to some degree that he is not gunning for us, at the very least. Others may be more moved by it and celebrate.. I say good for them. Wave that flag. We had enough fear from 9/11 that we need a balance of rejoicement. At least I feel it... good day to be an American.
[This message has been edited by tbone42 (edited 05-02-2011).]
He was explaining how it happened to the people. Overall he was not taking credit. And any credit that is given to him is done rightfully so, as does more credit go to the troops and other military leaders.
As for celebrating in his death... I will not say "Rot in Hell Osama". However, I'm happy my country is a tiny bit less in fear. I am happy my best friend who died in Afghanistan last year fought for something America can see. I'm happy we are seeing results. I'm happy there is, or will shortly be, a light at the end of the long tunnel we've been traveling on. And I'm happy that the >5,356 CIVILIAN deaths can now be somewhat eased, and sometime in the future we will see an end. No I'm not happy a life is now dead. This moment is shocking & historic. That doesn't mean people who are rejoicing are ignorant of the severity.
Is anyone else bothered by the celebrating in the streets? Dure it is mostly stupid college kids but it just unseemly. I'm glad he's dead but I wouldn't go screaming in front of the white house or in times square.
I don't know, but many were bothered by them dancing in the streets when the Twin Towers went down. Seems maybe we don't hold ourselves to a higher standard after all.
Personally, I'm happy they finally got him. It's been a long time coming. I for one won't be dancing in the streets though. It won't end the war and most likely retaliation will occur. Whether that retaliation is on our soil or not is yet unknown. I don't feel I am personally in any danger, although I do live below a Air Force Base. I think there are much larger targets out there and that a strike would most likely be done, if done, on the leadership, financial or military structure. I doubt the Air Force Base I live near would rate high up on that list. The only other possibility would be a Religion based retaliation, in which case Salt Lake City may be in danger since Utah is 60% LDS. We will see how it all plays out.
IP: Logged
01:59 AM
Scottzilla79 Member
Posts: 2573 From: Chicago, IL Registered: Oct 2009
Originally posted by 1988holleyformula: I get where you're coming from, but I would counter with the fact that it at least raises spirits. Let a country that has been riddled with economic problems and a general depressing mood celebrate and be merry, no matter the occasion.
For some people, it just floats their boat to be extra patriotic, and I would never discourage them.
While I understand what you're saying, I will never celebrate the killing of another life, no matter how necessary, nor will I applaud those who do so, no matter how motivated. I recognize that killing can be a necessity. That does not mean that anyone should ever celebrate wantonly at the event of another's death, nor should any human, regardless of his mental or economic wherewithal, be supported in celebration of the death of another.
Apparently, your position is: "Oh, we just needed something to celebrate!" Then where does that place you in moral relation to those who danced in the streets when thousands were murdered as the Twin Towers collapsed?
Because you see yourself as no different from them, we don't need to be having this conversation.
Then instead of celebrating Bin Laden's death, celebrate the end of a dark chapter in America's history. We got our closure. Now we can look forward to better times.
IP: Logged
02:25 AM
PFF
System Bot
mptighe Member
Posts: 3321 From: Houston, TX Registered: Aug 2009
Originally posted by Shyster: While I understand what you're saying, I will never celebrate the killing of another life, no matter how necessary, nor will I applaud those who do so, no matter how motivated. I recognize that killing can be a necessity. That does not mean that anyone should ever celebrate wantonly at the event of another's death, nor should any human, regardless of his mental or economic wherewithal, be supported in celebration of the death of another.
Apparently, your position is: "Oh, we just needed something to celebrate!" Then where does that place you in moral relation to those who danced in the streets when thousands were murdered as the Twin Towers collapsed?
Because you see yourself as no different from them, we don't need to be having this conversation.
Just out of curiousity, you're passing judgment on someone that can understand why people would celebrate the passing of their enemy? Would you also judge the people of Iraq that celebrated the death of Saddam, or the Jews across the world celebrating the death / defeat of Hitler? While I can understand your desire to honor all life, this is a reality in our society. He was not a confused soul that took a few lives. If he had the opportunity, he MAY have attempted genocide. People are not celebrating the extinguishing of a live, they are celebrating the end of a life that served to take other lives. I do not necessarily agree with the celebrating, and I believe you have the right to think how you want, but I don't think you have the right to judge them or people who understand their desire to celebrate.
I'm trying not to assume too much about you, but there are a few tells that I'm curious about. You say there are more important things in the world, as you sit in front of your computer, living in Conroe (a very affluent area), and obviously have a higher education by your vocabulary (does shyster mean lawyer?). I would say you have a fairly materialistic life as most Americans do. What have you done to address these more important concerns? What did you do today to end hunger, war, oppression, homelessness, poverty? Believe me, I don't necessarily disagree, I get sickened by the constant media and virtual reality, but I'm not going to participate in it while hypocritically chastizing others.
Just some food for thought.
IP: Logged
02:33 AM
exoticse Member
Posts: 8650 From: Orlando, Fl Registered: Jun 2003
As he should, Any other President would. It rightfully happened on his watch, if there was an attack on us he would be blamed, why not take credit for the good?
Brad
hehehe agreed. What would you expect him to do ? Not take any credit ??
Sure he didn't pull the trigger, but he absolutely had a hand in what went down.
Just because a coach doesn't throw the football, doesn't mean he doesn't deserve credit for winning the super bowl !
We all understand the troops are the real heroes in this.
I understand some people don't like the guy but trying to undermine this as something less than a major important historical moment that will help define the president is pretty silly.
[This message has been edited by exoticse (edited 05-02-2011).]
IP: Logged
02:34 AM
fierobear Member
Posts: 27079 From: Safe in the Carolinas Registered: Aug 2000
Man, screw you Troll. All I stated was a FACT, and that the announcement came on the 8th anniversary of "Mission Accomplished".. It was the observation of a coincidence, I never said one demeaning thing about Bush, or anything for that matter until now. Go stir a turd on someone else.
Up yours, ass. The "mission accomplished" banner was for the SHIP, but you're trying to make it something else. That's STUPID DEMOCRAT S***. Own up to it.
IP: Logged
02:38 AM
fierobear Member
Posts: 27079 From: Safe in the Carolinas Registered: Aug 2000
Wow, seriously? This news breaks and all some people can think to do is argue politics?
I clicked on this thread to read and celebrate, and the anti-Bush crowd went right to the same horseshit. I would have liked to celebrate, too. Bummer, huh?
Up yours, ass. The "mission accomplished" banner was for the SHIP, but you're trying to make it something else. That's STUPID DEMOCRAT S***. Own up to it.
Up yours as well. The whole thing was a photo op, as shown by his silly flight jacket. Mr. AWOL from the ANG.
IP: Logged
02:43 AM
fierobear Member
Posts: 27079 From: Safe in the Carolinas Registered: Aug 2000
Originally posted by weaselbeak: "Huh? As soon as "I" took office, "I" ordered Leon Panetta to make this a priority. (Not even, "I reaffirmed the priority set by my predecessor.")(NOPE! "I" gave this order !!!) "I" was briefed (eight months ago). "I" ordered further investigations. "I" ordered action."
Sorry, Shyster, It was not a reinforced priority. Bush stated clearly that he was not that important, more than once. Obama made it a priority again. He did give the order, unless there is a CIC we aren't aware of. "I ordered action" is exactly what happened.
OK, so then Obama DID take credit, which is exactly what the previous posters (not you, mind you) asserted. QED.
But get real. Do you think Bush was incapable of dissembling when necessary? There was a huge open reward for Bin Laden's head all that time. Do you really think he wasn't an active target prior to Obama taking office? Or are you openly claiming that every public statement made by a public official is irrefutable "fact?"
Let's face reality. Ever since Carter screwed the pooch on the Iran hostage "rescue," no CE has been willing to take any risk at all. Bush probably could have had Bin Laden half a dozen times. We'll never know. It's either absolute success, or we're not going. All of which means, Bin Laden screwed up, big time. He got comfortable, he got secure.
This man, who needed routine kidney dialysis, managed to elude everything we threw at him for almost a decade. Either he got stupid, or he got tired.
Either way, I'm not in a big hurry to sing the praises of any administration for finally stumbling into him.
IP: Logged
02:47 AM
fierobear Member
Posts: 27079 From: Safe in the Carolinas Registered: Aug 2000
So those who celebrated the death of one man who was responsible (at least partially) for the shed blood of thousands of innocent people are no different then those who cheered in the streets at the loss of 3000+ people based only on the fact that they hate the western civilization?
Hardly the same, IMO. When I see crowds of people celebrating cities full of civilians being bombed in the middle east for no reason other than it's a craphole, then I'll think differently.
IP: Logged
02:48 AM
fierobear Member
Posts: 27079 From: Safe in the Carolinas Registered: Aug 2000
Up yours, ass. The "mission accomplished" banner was for the SHIP, but you're trying to make it something else. That's STUPID DEMOCRAT S***. Own up to it.
You're out of your mind. Wow. I am not even sure you have read what I posted. I have never seen such stupidity in my life as what you have just spewed forth. If you can't keep straight even who you are arguing with, you deserve to look like the assclown you now look like. I'm assuming you must be drinking because normally you aren't THIS dense.. I got better things to do than hold a troll's hand in conversation. If you can't figure it out thats your shortcoming. Friggin loonie.
[This message has been edited by tbone42 (edited 05-02-2011).]
IP: Logged
02:58 AM
Shyster Member
Posts: 1085 From: Conroe, TX, USA Registered: Aug 2005
Originally posted by mptighe: Just some food for thought.
Not to take your food out of order here, but this is way off-topic, as analysis of my personality or economic status (if any), does not have anything to do with this thread. So, you have a PM. You have my permission to share the contents of that PM with anyone who's curious (for whatever reason), or to start another thread, as if the world needed it.
IP: Logged
03:02 AM
fierobear Member
Posts: 27079 From: Safe in the Carolinas Registered: Aug 2000
You're out of your mind. Wow. I am not even sure you have read what I posted. I have never seen such stupidity in my life as what you have just spewed forth. If you can't keep straight even who you are arguing with, you deserve to look like the assclown you now look like. I'm assuming you must be drinking because normally you aren't THIS dense.. I got better things to do than hold a troll's hand in conversation. If you can't figure it out thats your shortcoming. Friggin loonie.
Really, dumbass? Here is YOUR post that I was responding to:
quote
Originally posted by tbone42:
Announcement of bin Laden's death comes on the eighth anniversary of former President George W. Bush's controversial "mission accomplished" statement aboard the U.S.S. Abraham Lincoln after the March 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq.
...and you call ME an assclown? Christ, tbone, I've had 3 beers and I can STILL out argue you with simple facts. Did I need to use larger type and bold?
From someone who could care less about the "president A's dick is bigger than president B's dick" discussion, I think it's incredibly stupid to even announce OBL is dead. That alone makes a martyr out of him. It would have been much better to have kept that a secret and let the Al Qaida network (and all other OBL fanboys) guess about OBL's whereabouts.
Gloating over the death of the world's biggest terrorist leader? Stupid, stupid, stupid.
IP: Logged
03:12 AM
fierobear Member
Posts: 27079 From: Safe in the Carolinas Registered: Aug 2000