It's now over so I can let the cat out of the bag. When I made the first post, Brooke had just got a pass on the first round of American Idol. This past Sunday, Brooke went back to Nashville for round 2. She got another pass for round 2 and then round 3 came right after. Round 3 was for 1 judge (some executive producer of the show). Thats where her trip ended.

I couldn't say anything about her trying out for American idol cause her and her dad had to sign confidentiality statements. If anything had gotten printed or posted on the net, she would have been disqualified.
Here is the email her dad (Mike) sent out explaining what happened...
16 year old Brooke's journey on American Idol ended this past weekend in the 3RD Round round with these words......
Brooke, the problem I have with you, is that you sound too much like Carrie Underwood, and every other Country Artist. We don't know who Brooke REALLY is! ............................Sorry, It's a NO!!
(AMERICAN IDOL EXECUTIVE PRODUCER KEN WARWICK)
IDOL was a tremendous experience for Brooke, and she is deeply disappointed, but the experience will strengthen her. Brooke beat
out 15,700 Singers in the first round to join 300 others in the Executive Producer Round, sailed through the 2nd round in front of 3 top producers, and was nixed by the "top dog" before the T.V. Judges round. And if her "problem" is sounding too much like Carrie Underwood, it's a problem that she's willing to live with!
MY TAKE ON AMERICAN IDOL
For those that follow American Idol, my personal observation, now that I have experienced it with Brooke from behind the scenes and
up close and personal, is that it is a Reality Show in the truest sense. I have wondered over the years when I've watched the show why
most of the top 10 or top 20 finalists never really seem to have much experience in terms of performing professionally. It seems to me
that if you have a show who's purpose is to find the best singers in America, each year the finalists would be loaded with polished
performers from across the country. The truth,as I have observed in these auditions,and now after talking to people who are well acquainted
with the show, is that Idol is looking for the story line. The guy or girl who worked on the farm (Carrie Underwood) and sang in the church choir, or the urban guy or girl from the "hood" who is trying to to beat the odds to get away from the poverty (Fantasia Burrino), or the girl who's Mother abandoned her when she was a child and her Dad went to prison (Kellie Pickler).
Bottom line is that, you still have to be a great singer, but you need a good story to really go far on the show. Combined with the "freak show" that they include in the first couple of weeks of the show (that being the people who really suck but think they can sing), and you have the number one show on T.V.! We saw this after the first audition in Nashville, backstage where the golden ticket winners were gathered in a room and asked to write an essay on anything interesting in their lives other than music. What was never asked in any of the auditions that Brooke went through were questions about their music background or performing experience. They also made it crystal clear that there was no interest in any original music. They also admitted in addressing the call back performers before they auditioned for the 3rd round that they weren't necessarily looking for the best voices, but were looking for the people who were "interesting". That is our American Idol experience that I would like to share. It may sound like sour grapes, but is not meant to be, just thought some of you might find it interesting! We really did enjoy the experience!
[This message has been edited by JimmyS (edited 09-23-2010).]