Edited to add: THIS IS A THREAD ABOUT MY BUILDING A CALIFORNIA SMOG LEGAL 3.4 DOHC 5-SPEED 1988 FIERO. IF YOU DON'T LIVE IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, THIS TECHNICAL DISCUSSION PROBABLY WILL BE OF NO INTEREST TO YOU. IT IS NOT A PLACE TO VENT YOUR DISLIKE OF ALL THINGS CALIFORNIA. THANK YOU FOR YOUR CO-OPERATION.
Just short of six years since I started the swap, it made it through the CARB referee. I can't speak about all of them, but the tech here was very knowledgeable about even our somewhat obscure cars. Just for future reference for anyone going through the process, it seemed the two things most examined during the visual were the intake manifold and the air cleaner. I had applied some raised lettering to the manifold (a very clean job if I say so myself) and he questioned me about it being "aftermarket". No problem after I explained how I did it myself. However, I was using the stock Fiero air cleaner and that didn't pass. I had to come back with a Lumina unit wired in place and then I was good to go.
I say he was knowledgeable because he did raise the car and inspected underneath with a flashlight. At the end when he was explaining about the air cleaner he said "I see you have a rear exhaust manifold mounted upside down on the front of the motor". Man, with all A/C hoses, wiring, coolant hose and heat blanket in there, he couldn't have seen much of it to recognize that.
After it passed he was very complimentary of the car. He said the LQ1 looked like a perfect match to the car.
Anyway, it's done and I can finish buttoning it all up. Thank you to everyone here on the forum for all the help when I needed it. You've been great!
Next: Finish hooking up the Corvette power steering install.
------------------ 1988 GT, 5-speed, white, beechwood leather, 3.4 DOHC crate motor with Getrag 5-speed. 6-speed installation is next.
[This message has been edited by sspeedstreet (edited 12-30-2010).]
IP: Logged
05:34 PM
PFF
System Bot
iluvsd619 Member
Posts: 1036 From: san diego, ca Registered: May 2005
Nice! Three of us is doing that swap down here in San Diego. Anything very important that we need to know before we see the ref? Can you post pics of your swap. Congrats on passing, we are right behind you.
IP: Logged
08:28 PM
Old Lar Member
Posts: 13797 From: Palm Bay, Florida Registered: Nov 1999
I'm afraid I didn't take a lot of photos while in process. Most of a LQ1 install is documented elsewhere, but I did a few details differently.
The only thing I can think of I had to redo because I was unhappy with the results was the main harness. I started with a 1992 Lumina harness and did a lot of the initial work on the bench; tagging all the connectors, removing the right side electrical center (redirecting the relay wiring in a bundle to be connected to the Fiero relays) and redirecting the wires that would connect to the C500 plug.
The motor/Getrag was mounted on a spare cradle on a stand so the assembly was at chest level. That way I wouldn't have to work on my hands and knees. I then put the harness on to the motor and connected to all the sensors, coils etc. Compared to the Fiero 2.8 wiring/plumbing mess the 3.4 DOHC harness looks bare-bones. Once the new harness could be further directed to their final destinations. I used a lot of zip-ties to sort everything and lay out lengths.
It was at this point I started dealing with the wires that would pass through into the passenger compartment for the ECM (I used the stock location), the C203 plug and the ALDL connector. I decided life would be easier if there was a plug for all that in the engine compartment. I used a Ford Taurus water tight plug (has about 40 connectors) and mounted it to the firewall next to the pass-through:
Now the harness length was a little less critical and the whole thing can be disconnected without dealing with the passenger compartment. Likewise, the ECM, C203 plug and the ALDL connector could be wired from the inside of the car to the Taurus plug separately from the main harness.
Once the engine-trans assembly was in the car the final lengths to the C500 and to the relays was determined and the plugs installed. I kind of went over the top on all my connectors, disassembling them, putting new terminals on the wires and reassembling them. I won't say I have no splices in the harness, but I tried to have as few as possible. A word on splicing: I soldered all my joints and used dual-wall shrink tube to cover them. Dual-wall is regular shrink tube that has been lined with a thin coating of a hot glue type plastic. When you heat the tube to shrink it, the liner melts and oozes out each end. This serves two purposes: one, obviously, is to keep dirt, grease and water out of the joint. Second is to keep the tube from ever sliding out of place (it happens).
It was at this point I found I had a problem. I have air conditioning on my car and I had left the coils in stock location on the lower front of the motor. There simply wasn't room between the motor and firewall for all that had been put there. I decided (for a lot of reasons) to move the coils to the top of the motor. I had considered this initially in the swap; it just seems like a stupid place to put them. So I built a bracket that mounts them over the C500 plug (my battery is up front). The plug wires are much shorter and and a lot of the DIS wiring goes to the C500 anyway. I made a few other changes along the way. My MAP sensor is mounted to the firewall to get it out of the way of the deck lid. More wires to reroute. At this point I started to rethink the two bulky plugs leading to the top of the motor. I eliminated them and only have the fuel injector wire coming up that way. Even with these changes it's a squeeze getting the A/C hoses through.
When the harness was completed you can picture it like this: It's a continuous bundle between the firewall pass-through (Taurus plug in my case) draped in front of the motor over to the C500 plug. A large branch goes over top of the bellhousing for sensors and senders. If I were to redo it I'd run the fuel injector wires through there as well. Take care with protecting this bundle from your crossover exhaust pipe, it gets darn hot in there. All other connections (starter, A/C, oil pressure, etc. are picked up as the bundle passes by.
After all was said and done, I realized I had made no provision for the temperature gauge sender. The LQ1 has a warning light switch in the head, but no sender for a gauge. I ended up mounting mine in the water pump and wiring it to it's position in the C500, but that's not a good location. It gives you a reading of the coolant at its lowest temperature, not its highest as it comes out of the motor.
I'll try to answer any questions you might have.
IP: Logged
02:22 PM
87antuzzi Member
Posts: 11151 From: Surrounded by corn. Registered: Feb 2009
Cool and congrats. Did you have to install the AIR stuff as well as I see it's a stick shift.
Yes, you can see it in the first photo, running between the back of the motor and the trunk. I was lucky enough to find two California 5-speed front manifolds and the plumbing to hook it all together. The pump itself is an EBay unit off a Chevy Tahoe. The referee took note it was there but never questioned it or checked if it functioned.
As far as the other comments, I enjoyed doing a clean, legal install. If you don't, then stay where you are.
[This message has been edited by sspeedstreet (edited 01-02-2011).]
IP: Logged
02:32 PM
madcurl Member
Posts: 21401 From: In a Van down by the Kern River Registered: Jul 2003
Used to live in California, Loved the area, loved the amazing beauty of the mountains and the ocean, wouldn't take a million dollars to go back there....... The government and regulations are off the charts ridiculous and you basically cannot do anything without getting an inspection or a permit.... forget it.... peace
Pete
IP: Logged
02:35 PM
PFF
System Bot
sspeedstreet Member
Posts: 2306 From: Santa Maria, CA Registered: Dec 2002
Did the rep plug into your system the check for codes? Or did he simply use the sniffer?
Sure, he plugged in. I didn't realize I had a bunch of stored codes from when I had one of the computer plugs work loose early on. I cleared them and was good to go.
[This message has been edited by sspeedstreet (edited 12-30-2010).]
IP: Logged
02:37 PM
sspeedstreet Member
Posts: 2306 From: Santa Maria, CA Registered: Dec 2002
Used to live in California, Loved the area, loved the amazing beauty of the mountains and the ocean, wouldn't take a million dollars to go back there....... The government and regulations are off the charts ridiculous and you basically cannot do anything without getting an inspection or a permit.... forget it.... peace
Pete
I disagree, but to each his own.
IP: Logged
02:39 PM
madcurl Member
Posts: 21401 From: In a Van down by the Kern River Registered: Jul 2003
Sure, he plugged in. I didn't realize I had a bunch of stored codes from when I had one of the computer plus work loose early on. I cleared them and was good to go.
I'm assuming it was the 3.4's computer prom, right?
Originally posted by sspeedstreet: As far as the other comments, I enjoyed doing a clean, legal install. If you don't, then stay where you are.
So because you have to jump through hoops to do something that we can do whenever we want with no problems makes you better?
I am not breaking any laws if I put whatever engine with whatever transmission in my Fiero. I don't have to have permission from anyone to drive it because of a certain engine combo, and I never will, there is talk of doing away with our already minor inspection as it is.
California is not the center of the world man, you guys are treated like prisoners and don't even realize how bad you got it, just because the Warden says you got it good, does not mean you do. Nice looking car though.
Brad
IP: Logged
03:47 PM
sspeedstreet Member
Posts: 2306 From: Santa Maria, CA Registered: Dec 2002
So because you have to jump through hoops to do something that we can do whenever we want with no problems makes you better?
I am not breaking any laws if I put whatever engine with whatever transmission in my Fiero. I don't have to have permission from anyone to drive it because of a certain engine combo, and I never will, there is talk of doing away with our already minor inspection as it is.
California is not the center of the world man, you guys are treated like prisoners and don't even realize how bad you got it, just because the Warden says you got it good, does not mean you do. Nice looking car though.
Brad
Well, Brad, this not a political discussion. If you have such a problem with California and it laws, stay the hell out. Fine by me. That said, this is not a thread you have anything to add to.
Neil
IP: Logged
04:19 PM
87antuzzi Member
Posts: 11151 From: Surrounded by corn. Registered: Feb 2009
Well, Brad, this not a political discussion. If you have such a problem with California and it laws, stay the hell out. Fine by me. That said, this is not a thread you have anything to add to.
Neil
Why are you so angry? I have paid the state of california almost 4k in fines. I still owe them a little over a grand. Why? Because I wanted a boosted volvo and a boosted fiero. I had CHP go through and write ticket after ticket on the fiero for not having CARB parts. I also got nailed to the wall in my cummins for having water/meth. Hell, they even got me for having a lowered car. I had to go to court many times over small crap that seems to have nothing to do with actual emissions. After a while I just quit caring on what was legal and what was not. No more going to get the car BARED or getting smog. I am happy for the people who have the money to get a legal swap done. Lets face it....it is not cheap to get a legal swap up and running in california. Well, its almost time for work. Im gonna go hop in the 85 with a 3.1 no cat and a loud exhaust and NOT get pulled over by chp over it. You have fun in cali.
IP: Logged
04:27 PM
sspeedstreet Member
Posts: 2306 From: Santa Maria, CA Registered: Dec 2002
I guess I've become oversensitive to the knee-jerk bashing of California whenever it's mentioned on this forum. The fact is, no-one has the self-proclaimed right to disregard the law unless you're willing to accept the consequences.
IP: Logged
04:56 PM
madcurl Member
Posts: 21401 From: In a Van down by the Kern River Registered: Jul 2003
Thanks for the info. I too have a Fiero N* that I hope to have CARB approve. Oh yeah, how did it pass the 5-speed test? Did the 3.4 original come with auto and 5-speed too?
------------------
"Friends don't let their friends drive stock."
IP: Logged
05:17 PM
87antuzzi Member
Posts: 11151 From: Surrounded by corn. Registered: Feb 2009
Thanks for the info. I too have a Fiero N* that I hope to have CARB approve. Oh yeah, how did it pass the 5-speed test? Did the 3.4 original come with auto and 5-speed too?
I chose the LQ1 because it was delivered to California 1991-1993 with a 5-speed. I had planned to do the Short* till I found out I couldn't do the manual. I'm not a small block fan, but I guess that new CARB legal crate motor from GM with a manual would be something to consider.
IP: Logged
05:40 PM
kevin Member
Posts: 2722 From: Elk Grove, CA USA Registered: Jan 2000
I gotta tell you, when I got my CARB door sticker, it was the prettiest "decal" I had ever seen... yours is the second prettist. CONGRATS!!!
Regards,
David
------------------ Metallic Blue/Silver 1987 Fiero GT - 2006 3800 Series III Drive by Wire; Ported & Polished by TrippleEdge; 1.7 Yella Terra Full Roller Rockers; VS Cam; Tuning by Darth; WCF CAI & 1 5/8 Stainless Headers, 3" Exhaust, Power Steering & Much More; MSD Coils & Wires; Porsche (Brembo) Calipers on 13" Viper Rotors; 18X8 TSW Indy Wheels.
IP: Logged
09:42 PM
Dec 31st, 2010
Fierobsessed Member
Posts: 4782 From: Las Vegas, NV Registered: Dec 2001
Edited to add: THIS IS A THREAD ABOUT MY BUILDING A CALIFORNIA SMOG LEGAL 3.4 DOHC 5-SPEED 1988 FIERO. Just short of six years since I started the swap, it made it through the CARB referee. I can't speak about all of them, but the tech here was very knowledgeable about even our somewhat obscure cars. Just for future reference for anyone going through the process, it seemed the two things most examined during the visual were the intake manifold and the air cleaner. I had applied some raised lettering to the manifold (a very clean job if I say so myself) and he questioned me about it being "aftermarket". No problem after I explained how I did it myself. However, I was using the stock Fiero air cleaner and that didn't pass. I had to come back with a Lumina unit wired in place and then I was good to go.
I say he was knowledgeable because he did raise the car and inspected underneath with a flashlight. At the end when he was explaining about the air cleaner he said "I see you have a rear exhaust manifold mounted upside down on the front of the motor". Man, with all A/C hoses, wiring, coolant hose and heat blanket in there, he couldn't have seen much of it to recognize that.
After it passed he was very complimentary of the car. He said the LQ1 looked like a perfect match to the car.
Anyway, it's done and I can finish buttoning it all up. Thank you to everyone here on the forum for all the help when I needed it. You've been great!
Next: Finish hooking up the Corvette power steering install.
Just found this, congrats!, and thank you for sharing!
IP: Logged
11:20 AM
Isolde Member
Posts: 2504 From: North Logan, Utah, USA Registered: May 2008
So because you have to jump through hoops to do something that we can do whenever we want with no problems makes you better?
I am not breaking any laws if I put whatever engine with whatever transmission in my Fiero. I don't have to have permission from anyone to drive it because of a certain engine combo, and I never will, there is talk of doing away with our already minor inspection as it is.
California is not the center of the world man, you guys are treated like prisoners and don't even realize how bad you got it, just because the Warden says you got it good, does not mean you do. Nice looking car though.
Brad
If you live in the U.S. of A., then there are federal laws, in effect , stating what you can and cannot do, regarding engine swapping, to any '68-up car. They may not be actively enforced in all parts of this nation, at this time, but Obama IS working on that. The laws are not well-thought-out, and are somewhat counter-productive in some aspects, but if you can't afford to do a legal swap, you shouldn't do any swap. Even the bad laws we have now still allow the best engines into any vehicle. There's nothing ever built that can't legally receive some version or other of the LSx engine family.
IP: Logged
11:33 AM
sspeedstreet Member
Posts: 2306 From: Santa Maria, CA Registered: Dec 2002
An engine swap does take a lot of time and money. Mine took six years! I never once walked away from it or "took a break". I just never spent more than an hour at a time at it before I needed something I didn't have or a part previously ordered was wrong or a custom part I'd made was 1/64" too thick. Of course, stretching it out like this makes it more affordable over time, but I never considered it would take this long when I started.
As far as gas mileage, I haven't checked yet. No point when I spend most of the time with my foot down on my new toy.. This weekend my wife and I are driving it to Santa Barbara (150 miles round trip). I'll post that mileage next week. This is a bone stock install with a 0 mile crate motor, so this will be a good baseline for the swap
[This message has been edited by sspeedstreet (edited 12-31-2010).]
IP: Logged
01:40 PM
88White3.4GT Member
Posts: 1604 From: Hayward, CA Registered: Dec 2003
However, I was using the stock Fiero air cleaner and that didn't pass. I had to come back with a Lumina unit wired in place and then I was good to go.
Specifically, why did he make you do this ? Doesn't seem to make sense.
quote
Originally posted by sspeedstreet:
THIS IS A THREAD ABOUT MY BUILDING A CALIFORNIA SMOG LEGAL 3.4 DOHC 5-SPEED 1988 FIERO. IF YOU DON'T LIVE IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, THIS TECHNICAL DISCUSSION PROBABLY WILL BE OF NO INTEREST TO YOU. IT IS NOT A PLACE TO VENT YOUR DISLIKE OF ALL THINGS CALIFORNIA. THANK YOU FOR YOUR CO-OPERATION.
This thread MIGHT be a nice Technical Reference if people pay attention to this.
IP: Logged
11:14 PM
Jan 1st, 2011
sspeedstreet Member
Posts: 2306 From: Santa Maria, CA Registered: Dec 2002
I'm not trying to split hairs, but really need to know - so the regs specifically say you need to use the air filter canister that came with the original engine ?
Also, i would really appreciate if you could post a link that has this stuff listed (i'm making a list)
Thanks.
IP: Logged
09:12 AM
87antuzzi Member
Posts: 11151 From: Surrounded by corn. Registered: Feb 2009
I'm not trying to split hairs, but really need to know - so the regs specifically say you need to use the air filter canister that came with the original engine ?
Also, i would really appreciate if you could post a link that has this stuff listed (i'm making a list)
Thanks.
No, you do not need the factory air box that came with the car. The way to get the intake done is buy one of the CARB legal intake tubes and cut it down. Then you are done. And if you SEARCHED there is plenty of info. Or talk to Chris West as he is the master in cali legal swaps.
IP: Logged
12:23 PM
sspeedstreet Member
Posts: 2306 From: Santa Maria, CA Registered: Dec 2002
It's a good question. I'm going to call the referee on Monday and ask for the reg.
Related . . . There's nothing I like about the Fiero air cleaner. It looks industrial and worst of all it catches water from the vent and rusts. I actually prefer the W-body cleaner, but there's no way it fits in there without making a custom base for it.
IP: Logged
05:44 PM
fieroguru Member
Posts: 12128 From: Champaign, IL Registered: Aug 2003
Can you post some better pics of the raised lettering on the intake? It looks cool and I would be interested in knowing what all you did to achieve the look.
IP: Logged
06:36 PM
Jan 2nd, 2011
PaulJK Member
Posts: 6638 From: Los Angeles Registered: Oct 2001
It's a good question. I'm going to call the referee on Monday and ask for the reg.
I'm really curious as to what he'll tell you. Look at the build thread that RickaddyGT did, especially page 4. There are pics of his car and a West Coast Fiero car and it doesn't look like either of them used the air cleaner from the original car (but it's hard to tell for sure).
There's nothing I like about the Fiero air cleaner. It looks industrial and worst of all it catches water from the vent and rusts. I actually prefer the W-body cleaner, but there's no way it fits in there without making a custom base for it.
Yep, it's almost impossible to mount anything in there EXCEPT the stock fiero air canister.
[This message has been edited by PaulJK (edited 01-02-2011).]
IP: Logged
05:13 AM
mcaanda Member
Posts: 3652 From: Grand Junction Colorado Registered: Mar 2003
I know you've been working for quite some time on it and that tag really says alot about the install quality and attention to detail. I've been w/ Rick to the ref's and they really do go over damn near every nut and bolt.
Congrats buddy...
--Allen
------------------ Is this where I insert something witty?
IP: Logged
10:17 AM
sspeedstreet Member
Posts: 2306 From: Santa Maria, CA Registered: Dec 2002